I've noticed that the #moonfruit hashtag is still at number on the the trending topics on Twitter this morning. This pisses me off.
Moonfruit are bribing Twitterers to use their hashtag in every conversation they have on Twitter by (supposedly) offering a macbook pro a day to someone who does. So yes, the campaign reached its objective of getting to number 1 on the trending topics like #squarespace did a few weeks ago.
But there are two reasons this pisses me off:
- So Moonfruit got to the top of trending topics. The problem is that it was done with an unrelated hashtag in random conversation so anyone browsing through the trending topics still doesn't have a clue what Moonfruit is or what they do. I also very much doubt it did much to the traffic on their website. So the campaign didn't drive traffic and didn't drive true awareness so what is the point.
- These competitions will stuff (and I really want to use a stronger word) up what hashtags are meant to be for and thats aggregating conversation so people can find related content. IE, lots of people were taking about Tweetcamp on the weekend so Tweetcamp trended (which was exciting for me!) and people browsing the trending page could get an idea of what it was about and related links. Moonfruit is trending but when you browse through the trending page the conversation is complety random. "Feeding my cat #moonfruit". What the hell is the point of that?! No one walks around in real life going "Good morning mate. Coca Cola".
So to sum it up: Clueless, old school, BS marketers stop stuffing (and I mean something else) up a very good system that is very helpful when used the right way. And if you were one of the guilty ones that got sucked into this and used the hashtag, shame on you. You're encouraging the clueless ones to do it more and eventually trending and hashtags will just be a pointless mess.
Posted via email from Jon's posterous